You beam as you gather your family ‘round the dining table, where you’ve lovingly assembled a colorful and nutritious meal. You serve the grilled chicken, the sauteed broccoli and the pumpkin-seed-studded salad. You nervously watch for reactions.
It’s really delicious… You swear!
Then, within moments, a floret of broccoli makes a perfect arc across the room after your toddler daughter catapults it from her fork. Your preteen son slumps so low that only his furrowed brow and the top of his phone peek above the table. Your partner, trying to be polite and supportive, has been chewing his first bite for a good two minutes. Without swallowing. Even the dog, usually hovering shamelessly, sniffs at a spinach leaf and then flops down in the corner with a sigh. You feel … alone.
To change your eating and exercise habits, do you have to convince your friends and family to change, too? Would getting loved ones on board with your healthy lifestyle changes make the whole endeavor easier?
And if so, how do you do that?
This really matters to you. You’re excited about your experiments with lifestyle changes. You’re eating more vegetables. You’re walking on your lunch breaks and seeing a trainer on the weekends. Your body is looking, working and feeling better. You feel sparks of inspiration and hope. And you want to keep going.
You desperately want loved ones with you.
Why? Well, because you love them. You want your family and friends to be healthy and safe—to feel good. You want to protect them from the pain of poor health. You want the best for them.
And frankly, you need support from the people closest to you. It seems hard—even near impossible—to make these big changes alone.
If you’re feeling these things, it’s important to know that the thoughts are really, really normal.
It is hard to eat and move in ways that support your own health goals when, in your social circle, Fridays mean beer and tacos, Saturdays mean a Jenga tower of bacon at the greasy spoon, and hanging out means meeting at the bar to shoot tequila instead of at the park to shoot hoops.
In some ways, you are the sum of your social circle.
In some ways, you are the sum of your social circle
Habits can be contagious.
The people around you matter. And you matter to the people around you.
Research shows that we are affected by the body composition, habits and lifestyles of those around us. The more people around us are doing something or living a certain way, the more likely we are to do and live the same—whether that’s what we eat, how we eat, whether we move (or not), how we move and so on.
If your friends and family are fitter and healthier, you’re more likely to be fitter and healthier. And the reverse is true, too.
Research shows that:
- The weight of those closest to you may help determine your own weight. According to one large-scale study, having a friend, an adult sibling or a spouse who is obese increases your own obesity risk by 57 percent, 40 percent and 37 percent, respectively.
- Even your friends’ friends matter. Two degrees of separation between you and someone who is obese increases your own chances of being obese by 20 percent. You don’t even have to have met them for this to be a factor in your own weight.
- Your social network affects your obesity risk exponentially. Each obese person you know is correlated with a 0.5 percent increase in your risk of obesity. Thus, having five obese social contacts more than doubles your risk of becoming obese.
- Your weight is more influenced by people of your own gender. For women, this means that a girlfriend or same-sex partner’s weight may have a larger effect than a guy friend or opposite-sex partner’s weight; and vice versa for men.
- Weight convergence likely happens subconsciously. Researchers believe that we change our habits to match those of our social group without talking or even thinking about it.
- The amount you eat depends on who you’re eating with. Dine with a big eater and you’re liable to consume more; sit down with a light eater and you’re likely to take in less. This effect has been observed even among strangers. When asked, the diners usually attribute the mirroring effect to taste and hunger as opposed to the behavior of others around them.
- How much you eat also depends on the size of the group you’re with. Eating with one, two, three, four, five, six and seven or more other people is associated with a 33, 47, 58, 69, 70, 72 and 96 percent increase in energy consumed, respectively.
- Your social network also can have a big impact on what you eat. People whose friends generally meet the guidelines for produce intake are more likely to eat at least five servings of fruit and vegetables per day.
- Your impression of social norms helps determine what you eat, how much you eat and your physical activity level. If getting a light salad for lunch seems “normal,” that’s what you’re likely to do, even if no one’s going to see you eat it. Conversely, if eating a bag of Ruffles for lunch seems “normal,” you may do that, even if you know the salad is more aligned with your health goals. Those who report a high level of physical activity as the social norm are also more likely to be active themselves.
As you can see, most of this happens subconsciously. We often change our habits to match those of our social group without talking or even thinking about it.
It’s not just how you eat and move, of course. Research indicates that you’re influenced by family and friends for other big-deal game changers, like whether to get married or when to have a baby. Of course, all these findings are correlations—researchers are still working out exactly why the body weight and lifestyle of friends and family affects your own.
But why does it work this way? Why can’t you be a lone wolf or a unique individual? Well, in some ways, social influence is a good thing. Social cohesion keeps us alive.
Social cohesion keeps us alive
Human beings are social creatures.
We evolved in small groups who depended on one another for survival. Much of our brain is devoted specifically to social cues and communication: recognizing faces, reading emotions, making and understanding language, etc. We depended on social cohesion—on belonging—to survive. To be alone (whether abandoned, rejected or left behind) often meant certain death.
Today, modern medicine shows us that loneliness can still kill: Our bodies respond to social rejection and isolation as if they were viral threats. When we are persistently lonely, inflammation goes up, immunity goes down; we get more chronic diseases and die sooner.
Aloneness is scary. Vulnerable. Difficult.
“Aloneness” can be real, like the actual aloneness of a young woman who chooses to stay in to eat a healthy dinner and get a good night’s sleep when all her roommates have gone out for pizza and partying.
“Aloneness” also can be a feeling, like the way a guy feels when all his buddies are drinking beer and he’s got a seltzer.
If you’re the only one at happy hour ordering a side salad instead of fries, it’s basically like you’re outside the campfire circle of social safety, just waiting for the lions to attack your tender, undefended flesh. Thus, protecting ourselves against aloneness is in our DNA.
Swimming against the current is hard
Of course, it is possible to go it alone. (Terms like “pioneer” and “trailblazer” exist, after all.)
But let’s face it: It’s a lot easier to eat better and get more movement when your social environment supports your goals. As with all things, the laws of physics come into play. When you’re trying to change, you may encounter either friction or momentum.
Friction can make you feel stuck.
Friction makes things harder to do.
Eye-rolling co-workers, spinach-resistant kids and chili-nacho-loving friends—people who explicitly disagree with you or simply engage in opposing habits create environmental and emotional barriers as you try to move toward your goals.
When you’re dealing with friction, lifestyle change is like climbing a steep mountain with gravel moving underneath you—complete with cursing, tripping and slow progress.
Momentum helps you keep rolling.
Momentum boosts you and replenishes your energy.
Willing and/or like-minded loved ones can help keep you accountable, connected and supported, bolstering you as you work to change your eating and workout routine.
Be brave; be positive.
Now here’s some “PN physics”: You can have friction and momentum together. In other words, even if you encounter resistance, you can still get support, too.
Even if your loved ones aren’t super enthusiastic about your nutrition and fitness experiments or will never love pea sprouts like you do, it doesn’t mean they don’t care or won’t help. You can pursue your goals in the face of wavering or stingy support. You don’t have to dump all your friends and family. Most important, you may not even have to try to convince anyone in order to get them on board.
Social support works both ways.
Social support works both ways. The people around you can influence you. And you can influence them back. This is where the good type of “going it alone” comes in: leadership.
While it may be easier to wait until your immediate social circle comes around to prioritizing healthy choices, it’s also incredibly empowering and inspiring to be a leader for change, despite the forces against you. And in doing so, you’ll build your own small wave of momentum that, little by little, erodes the friction you encounter.
But here’s an important tip: You don’t reduce friction by pushing back. A powerful healthy-lifestyle pioneer is a peaceful one.
In order to step into that role, try this gentle, sometimes counterintuitive, action plan.
Three crucial strategies for getting friends and family to support your healthy lifestyle
- Accept that you may not be “right”
Step back and embrace some hard truth. How much of the friction you feel from others is actually created by you?
Even if you mean well, and even if you are absolutely 100 percent correct (yes, smoking is bad; yes, vegetables are good). How often have you been judgmental? Insistent? Preachy? Self-righteous? Dismissive? Overenthusiastic? Maybe even a bit culty? (That T-shirt that says “Kale University?”e see it.)
Conversely, how often have you been curious? Interested in others’ perspectives? Able to deal with diversity and tolerate various viewpoints? Open-minded? Empathetic and compassionate? A good listener?
Consider this: Maybe “right” isn’t so obvious.
All behaviors and choices have a reason to be there. You might not know the reasons; you might not quite understand the reasons or even agree with the reasons. But whatever habits your loved ones are practicing, they are doing them for a reason. In some way, their habits are “right” for them. They may have only a limited toolbox of options or coping skills.
When we focus on defending our “rightness” and proving our loved ones’ “wrongness,” our perspective becomes very narrow and our relationships become oppositional.
However, when we let go of judgment and choose compassion and empathy, we make room for understanding.
Understanding dissolves conflict because it usually shows us that, at our cores, we are all dealing with the same themes—we’re more alike than different. Understanding helps us collaborate instead of clash, connect instead of criticize. We start to ask questions that, instead of inducing blame and shame, invite connection and support: “How do I get them to stop the bad habit?” becomes “What problem is the bad habit trying to solve?” and “What is wrong with them?” becomes “What might they really need?”
As your loved ones begin to feel more understood and less judged, they may begin to practice more flexibility and less judgment toward your new habits and beliefs, too. (And by the way, it’ll serve you immensely to practice non-judgment, compassion and understanding on yourself, too.)
- Be persistent, not pushy
Resistance more often comes from fear than from true philosophical opposition. Change can feel scary. It can bring up issues of control, security and identity, and it also can bring up painful emotions like anxiety, panic, shame or loss.
When our loved ones resist change (in all the creative ways they can come up with—consciously and unconsciously, kindly and unkindly), what they might actually be feeling underneath it all is fear. Just like a scared child, resistance and fear in their adult forms don’t respond well to rational arguments and pushing.
So while you must press forward with the changes you’re trying to make for your own well-being, you’ll more likely get support if you practice persistence rather than pushiness.
Pushiness means attempting to force friends and family to join/agree with you and accepting only a rigid set of compliant responses.
Persistence means continuously offering opportunities for your friends and family to join you on your quest for a healthier life and yet remains open to a wide range of responses to any given invitation.
So be persistent. Keep offering healthy dishes at the dinner table. Keep inviting your friends and family to join you on runs, hikes and exercise classes. Keep having conversations about nutrition, healthy body image and what it means to have a truly good, capable life.
Prioritize positivity and connection when you present these options and expect resistance, sometimes over and over and over again.
As much as you can, take the drama and emotional charge out of these conversations. Validate your loved ones’ reasons for staying the way they are, and don’t push back.
Perhaps when their fear subsides and they realize it’s safe to dip their toe in the land of green smoothies and box jumps, your loved ones will join you and you’ll ride off into the sunset (on your recumbent bikes, drinking coconut water) together.
- Just “do you”
Change is difficult. In order to overcome the many bumps, blocks and blusters inherent to significant lifestyle change, we need to be anchored to a deep, internal, personalized “why” that will pull us through.
You can’t manufacture this type of motivation for someone else. No matter how hard you try to coerce your kids, spouse, parents and friends to change, they may have none of it.
And in fact, that may be a good sign. Because that means they know that in order to make the kinds of changes you’re making, they have to want it, too.
We call this “intrinsic motivation”—a connection to one’s own, internal reasons for doing something. Research shows that intrinsic motivation leads to change that’s longer-lasting and more self-sustaining than extrinsic motivation, which is based on the desire to obtain external outcomes such as good grades or the approval of others (ahem).
Intrinsic motivation requires deep thought and reflection, and it may take longer to develop. So respect that your loved ones may take time to connect to their own reasons for eating and moving better.
Meanwhile, just do you. Focus on your own intrinsic motivations. Stay connected to what’s driving you, deep inside, to make these personal changes. Without ignoring your natural love and concern for loved ones, let your attention turn inward. Spend more energy on your own growth and development.
Which could lead to something else amazing…
By working toward and achieving a healthier, happier, more confident and capable version of yourself, you become the inspiration, the positive influence to your family and friends.
And it all comes full circle when that little healthy-lifestyle wave you started attracts other riders, builds and then becomes a huge tidal wave of momentum to carry you to your final objective—a fit, healthy you—and keep you there.
Influence happens in both directions, remember? Lead the way.
A longer version of this article originally appeared on PrecisionNutrition.com.
Photo credit: LaylaBird, Getty Images